(Last Update: 03/09/2024)

The right mattress is crucial for a good night's sleep and overall well-being.

A well-chosen mattress can vastly improve sleep quality, alleviate pain, and make waking up refreshed and energized a daily reality.

The process of choosing the perfect mattress may seem daunting. Still, this comprehensive mattress trials, warranties, and return policies guide will walk you through the essentials: understanding the "best mattress trial periods, warranties, and return policies, as well as top recommendations and tips for a successful mattress trial experience.


  • Understand mattress trial periods, break-in periods, return policies & warranties to make an informed decision.
  • Consider hidden costs and fees when returning a mattress for the optimal experience.
  • Read customer reviews & compare brands/offers based on type, firmness, etc., to find the best option for your needs.

Understanding Mattress Sleep Trial Periods

What is a mattress trial period?

A mattress trial period is when a customer can try out a new mattress in their home before making a final decision. Although sleep trials differ, most online mattress brands offer sleep trials, and most companies allow customers to return the newly purchased mattress for a full refund if unsatisfied.

A family Testing a Mattress in a Store.

(Credit: Canva)

How do mattress trial periods work?

Understanding how mattress trial periods work in your mattress purchase process is key to a satisfying purchase experience when shopping for a mattress. Many mattress manufacturers offer at-home trials, allowing you to test the mattress directly in your own space.

Whether you're a combination sleeper or have specific support needs, these free trials let you experience the mattress for more than just one or two nights. Hybrid mattresses and other types are often available for trial in mattress stores or through online orders.

The return process typically starts with a simple call or online request, ensuring that unwanted mattresses can be returned or exchanged, paving the way for better sleep without the commitment worries.

The terms and conditions of mattress sleep trial periods vary from brand to brand. However, most sleep trials follow a similar process:

Customers purchase their mattresses directly from an online mattress brand.

The mattress is shipped to the customer's home.

The customer has enough time to try the mattress (usually a break in 90 to 120 nights), and the average mattress trial period is between 100 to q20 nights.

For example, Mattress Firm provides free, secure delivery and a mattress trial length of 120 nights, ensuring you find your ideal bed with complete confidence and satisfaction. Customers unsatisfied with the mattress can return it for a full refund.

It's important to read the fine print and understand the average sleep trial period the mattress brand offers before committing to a purchase. Some mattress brands may have shorter sleep trials, while others offer mattress free sleep trials with no obligation to purchase. Some Online mattress companies offer the longest sleep trial of 365 days.

Remember that mattress trial periods and warranties may have conditions, such as a required break-in period or return fees. Understanding the mattress trial period terms will help ensure a smooth and hassle-free experience when trying out a new mattress. Assess the edge support during mattress trials to prevent experiencing less-than-ideal sleep.

A Man Enjoying a New Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)


A mattress break-in period in mattress-free trials is when your body adjusts to the mattress. It allows for full comfort and support assessment before deciding to keep or return the product.

The first required break-in period is an essential part of any sleep trial, typically spanning between 14 to 30 days of the sleep trial. This period allows your body to become accustomed to the new mattress and the mattress to adapt to your body.

Giving the mattress enough time to break in is crucial, as it might feel different from what you experienced in-store or during a few minutes of testing.

Suppose the mattress does not meet your expectations after the break-in period. In that case, please return through the channels outlined by the mattress company during the sleep trial and break-in period.

So, as you know, some companies require mattresses to be returned in their original packaging.

Return Policies Concept.

(Credit: Canva)

Return Procedures and Policies

The mattress return process typically starts when a buyer contacts the customer service representative. Return procedures and policies may vary depending on the online mattress companies, including who is responsible for pickup and the shipping costs.

Please be sure to familiarize yourself with the return process and any potential fees before purchasing a mattress.

Factors such as return shipping fees, restocking fees, or the cost of old mattress removal can impact the overall cost of returning a mattress.

Additionally, certain brands may offer options, such as exchanging the mattress for a different model from their selection.

Evaluating Mattress Warranties


A mattress warranty is a promise made by the mattress company to repair or replace any existing physical defects in the mattress for a certain period. It's a commitment from the mattress manufacturer to ensure customer satisfaction.


When evaluating a mattress warranty, there are a few things to remember:

Coverage: What is covered by the warranty? Does it cover manufacturing defects, excessive sagging, or anything else?

Duration: How long is the warranty in effect? Most warranties are for 10 years, but some are shorter or longer.

A Businessman Showing Warranty Word.

(Credit: Canva)

Full or partial refund: Does the warranty offer a full or partial refund if the mattress is defective?

It's important to read the fine print and understand the full terms of the warranty before purchasing. A comprehensive warranty from mattress manufacturers can provide peace of mind and protection against potential manufacturing defects, ensuring your investment in a new mattress is secure.

Additional tips for evaluating mattress warranties:

Compare warranties from different brands: Not all warranties are equal. Some brands offer more comprehensive warranties than others.

Read the fine print: Don't just skim the warranty. Please read it carefully and understand all the terms and conditions.

Please don't hesitate to contact the customer service representative of the mattress company if you have any questions about a warranty. They should happily answer your questions and help you understand the warranty.

A Family Enjoying their Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Types of Mattress Warranties

There are three types of mattress warranties: limited, full replacement, and prorated.

A limited warranty is a guarantee from the manufacturer to repair or replace any physical defects in a mattress. This guarantee is usually available within a specified period.

A full replacement warranty promises to replace the mattress should it exhibit any physical defects within the specified timeframe.

A prorated warranty is a guarantee from the manufacturer to repair or replace the mattress if it has any physical defects within a certain period. However, over time, the coverage of the warranty is reduced.

Factors That Can Void a Warranty

Certain factors, such as improper use, abuse, and neglect, can void a mattress warranty. Examples of customer negligence include failing to take proper care of the mattress, not rotating it regularly, or not using a mattress protector.

An improper foundation or frame that does not adhere to the manufacturer's specifications, such as utilizing a box spring unsuitable for the mattress, can invalidate the mattress warranty.

Staining, soiling, and fluid damage are all forms of damage that can invalidate a mattress warranty if not addressed promptly.

To maintain the validity of your mattress warranty, follow the manufacturer's care instructions and avoid actions that can void the warranty.

Comparing Return Policies

When shopping for a new mattress, comparing return policies is essential in decision-making.

Understanding the return policy of different brands helps buyers know what is covered and what fees may be incurred if they return the wrong mattress anyway.

Some mattress companies offer generous return policies with no restocking or return fees, while others may have more stringent conditions or charge additional fees.

Hidden Costs and Fees

Hidden costs and fees should be considered when returning a mattress. Some companies may charge return shipping fees or restocking fees, which can add up and impact the overall cost of the return.

Please know about these fees and factor them into your decision when choosing a replacement mattress to return your mattress to.

Also, shipping costs may be higher for more remote locations, so this should be considered when returning a mattress.

Some mattress companies may also void the free mattress trial period if the mattress has been ordered from a certain location, so it's crucial to know any location-specific terms and conditions that may apply to your mattress sleep trial.

A person testing a New Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Pickup Arrangements

Convenient pickup arrangements are important for remote users needing to return a mattress.

Mattress pickup arrangements involve collecting a mattress from the customer's location, which can vary depending on the company or service provider.

This may include scheduling a pickup date, placing the mattress for regular garbage collection, or making special arrangements in advance.

You should choose a company that offers convenient pickup arrangements for your location and situation. Ensuring a smooth and hassle-free pickup and return process will make the mattress return process much more manageable and less stressful.

Top Mattresses with Exceptional Trial Periods and Warranties

After considering all the factors and understanding the importance of trial periods and warranties, we've compiled a list of top mattresses with exceptional trial periods and warranties.

These mattresses include Puffy Lux Hybrid (101-night sleep trial period) and Nolah Natural (120-night sleep trial).

Brands With the Longest Sleep Mattress Trial

DreamCloud, Level Sleep, Awara, Avocado Vegan, and Nectar Memory Foam mattresses are prominent brands offering the longest sleep trial of 365 days . This gives customers ample time to test and adjust to their new mattress.

These mattresses offer trial periods, strong warranties, and excellent customer satisfaction.

It's important to remember that each individual's preferences and needs may differ, so consider each new mattress's specific features and benefits before making your final decision. The key is finding the ideal mattress that suits your unique sleeping style, comfort preferences, and budget.

Best Overall Mattress

The Puffy Lux Hybrid is our top pick for the best overall mattress, offering a 101-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty. This mattress is designed with a combination of foam layers and a cooling gel layer, providing excellent support, pressure relief, and temperature regulation for sleepers who sleep hot.

What sets the Puffy Lux Hybrid apart from most mattresses is its comprehensive sleeping experience that caters to various sleep positions and preferences.

With a balance of comfort and support, this mattress is an excellent choice for those seeking a high-quality option backed by a generous mattress trial period and warranty.

A Woman Enjoying a New Mattress .

(Credit: Canva)

Best Budget-Friendly Mattress

The Nectar Memory Foam mattress is an excellent choice for those seeking a more budget-friendly option. This mattress offers a 1-year free trial period and financing with 0% APR through Affirm, making it an affordable option without sacrificing quality or comfort.

The Nectar Memory Foam mattress is designed with multiple layers of foam and cooling gel, providing support and more pressure relief for various sleep positions and a hot sleeper.

With a lifetime warranty to back up its quality, the Nectar Memory Foam mattress is a smart choice for those looking for a budget-friendly new mattress with a generous free trial period and strong warranty coverage.

Tips for Maximizing Your Mattress Trial Experience

To make the most of your mattress trial experience, there are several tips you can follow. First, be sure to test the comfort and support of the mattress by trying it in different sleep positions and paying attention to how it responds to your body weight and contours.

Monitoring the quality of your sleep during the new mattress trial period is also essential, as it can help you determine whether the mattress fits your needs.

In addition to comfort and support testing, please ensure that the mattress is properly in the room where the mattress is placed. This can help with heat retention and reduce off-gassing odors from the mattress, making your mattress trial experience more pleasant and comfortable.

By following these tips, you can maximize your mattress sleep trial experience and make an informed decision about whether to keep or return the mattress.

For effective use of innerspring mattresses during sleep trials, ensure proper setup, maintain cleanliness, and regularly rotate the mattress.

A Young Black Couple Enjoying Their Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Testing Comfort and Support

When assessing the comfort and support of a mattress during the mattress trial period, it's important to note how the mattress feels when you lie down.

Try lying in different positions, such as on your back, side, or stomach, and observe how the mattress responds to your body weight and contours.

Pay attention to pressure relief, strong edge support, and how well the mattress supports your spine in various sleeping positions.

By thoroughly testing the comfort and support of the mattress, you can better determine if it's the right fit for your needs. Remember that your body may need some time to adjust to a new mattress, so be patient and give yourself enough time to experience the mattress during the mattress trial period fully.

Monitoring Sleep Quality

Monitoring your sleep quality during the mattress trial period is essential for determining whether the mattress fits your needs.

You can track your sleep patterns and comfort levels using wearable devices or smartphone applications like the Oura Ring, Fitbit Inspire 2, or Sleep Cycle app.

These tools can provide valuable insights into the quality of your sleep, such as heart rate, movement, and sleep stages.

By keeping track of the quality of your sleep during the new mattress trial period, you can make a more informed decision about whether the mattress is right for you.

If you notice consistent improvements in your sleep quality, it's a good indication that the mattress is a suitable choice.

On the other hand, if your sleep quality declines or doesn't improve, you may return your mattress and try a different option.

A Young Man back Sleeping on a Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

How to Choose the Right Mattress Online

Selecting a suitable mattress can be challenging. Still, there are several strategies you can employ to make the process easier and more successful.

Reading customer reviews can provide valuable insights into the quality of the mattress, the customer service experience, and the satisfaction of other customers.

Additionally, comparing brands and offers can help you find the best mattress that suits your needs and preferences.

By taking the time to research and compare mattress brands thoroughly, you can make a more informed decision about which mattress is right for you.

When selecting a new mattress on the Internet, consider your budget, sleeping position, body type, and desired materials.

This will help you find the perfect mattress that meets your unique needs and preferences.

Reading Customer Reviews

Reading customer reviews is essential in selecting and buying a mattress online. These reviews can offer useful information regarding the quality of the mattress, the customer service experience, and the level of satisfaction of other customers.

When analyzing customer reviews, it's important to identify any common themes or issues that may be present.

Additionally, the reviews' credibility should be considered, as well as both positive and negative reviews.

Amerisleep, Casper, Purple, and Sleep Number offer a money-back guarantee in their mattress trial. Each company's warranty covers various situations, and returned mattresses might have additional conditions. Be sure to understand the terms to avoid unexpected fees.

By carefully reading customer reviews, you can better understand the pros and cons of a particular mattress and any potential issues that may arise.

This information can help you make a more informed decision when choosing the appropriate mattress, ensuring a more satisfying purchase experience.

An African American sleeping On Their Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Comparing Brands and Offers

Comparing various online mattress companies and offers is another crucial step in choosing the appropriate mattress online. Factors such as mattress type, firmness, support for various sleeping positions, temperature control, motion isolation, durability, price, and return policy/warranty should be considered when comparing online mattress brands and offers.

You can find the best option that suits your unique needs and preferences by thoroughly evaluating and comparing various brands and offers.

This will help ensure that you make a well-informed decision and invest in a mattress that will provide you with a comfortable and supportive sleeping surface for years to come.


In conclusion, understanding mattress trial periods, warranties, and return policies is crucial when selecting the right mattress online.

Following the tips and recommendations in this guide, you can make a more informed decision and choose the perfect mattress that meets your unique needs and preferences.

Don't hesitate to take advantage of mattress trial periods and warranties to ensure that you're investing in a mattress that will provide you with the comfortable and supportive sleep you deserve.

Happy Couple Comfortably Enjoying their Their Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens to mattresses that are returned after the sleep trials?

Most mattress companies that make new mattresses offer a free trial period, allowing customers to donate the mattress if unsatisfied with their purchase. In other cases, new mattresses can be recycled or thrown away.

Some companies may even repurpose the returned mattress and resell it at a reduced price. Overall, returned mattresses have plenty of viable options to ensure they are put to good use.

How long should I try a mattress before returning it?

It is recommended to try out a new mattress for at least 30 days before initiating a return. Take the time to get used to your new bed and ensure it fits you. Give yourself enough time to decide if this bed is the one you want, but take your time beyond the return window!

Young Man Soundly Sleeping on a Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Are mattress trials worth it?

If you need more clarification about the type of mattress you want, a mattress trial can help you make an educated decision. You can try out different mattresses in person or online before committing can give you some useful feedback on the support, comfort, and feel of each mattress.

Overall, mattress sleep trials are a great way to determine which mattress is right for you.

Can I return a mattress if I don't like it?

You can likely return the mattress if you don't like it, as most companies will allow returns. However, please check out their policies online or in person before buying a mattress online to ensure you know of any potential restrictions.

Share this post