(Last Update: 07/01/2024)

The right mattress is crucial for a good night's sleep and overall well-being.

A well-chosen mattress can vastly improve sleep quality, alleviate pain, and make waking up refreshed and energized a daily reality.

A good night’s sleep and overall health depend on the right mattress.

A good mattress can significantly enhance the quality of your sleep, reduce pain, and help you feel refreshed and energized daily.

Choosing the perfect mattress can seem overwhelming. But this mattress trials, warranties, and returns guide will break it down for you: the best mattress trial periods, warranties and returns, and top tips and advice for a successful mattress trial.


  • Know mattress trial periods, break-in periods, returns, and warranties.
  • Consider hidden costs and fees when returning a mattress.
  • Read reviews & compare brands/offers by type, firmness, etc., to find the best for you.

Mattress Sleep Trial Periods

What is a mattress trial period?

A mattress trial period is when a customer can try a new mattress in their home before making a final decision. Although sleep trials differ, most online mattress brands offer sleep trials, and most companies allow customers to return the newly purchased mattress for a full refund if unsatisfied.

A family Testing a Mattress in a Store.

(Credit: Canva)

How do mattress trial periods work?

Knowing how mattress trial periods work in your purchase process is key to a happy purchase. Many mattress companies offer at-home trials so you can try the mattress in your space.

Whether you’re a combination sleeper or have specific support needs, these free trials let you try the mattress for more than one or two nights. Hybrid mattresses and others are available to try in-store or online.

The return process usually starts with a simple phone call or online request. This way, unwanted mattresses can be returned or exchanged, and there are no commitment worries.

The terms and conditions of mattress sleep trial periods vary from brand to brand. But most sleep trials follow this process:

Customers buy their mattresses directly from an online mattress brand.

The mattress is shipped to the customer’s home.

The customer has time to try the mattress (usually a break in 90 to 120 nights), and the average mattress trial period is between 100 to 20 nights.

For example, Mattress Firm offers free, secure delivery and a 120-night mattress trial to find your perfect bed with complete confidence and satisfaction. Customers who are happier with the mattress can return it for a full refund.

Please read the fine print and know the average sleep trial period of the mattress brand before you buy. Some mattress brands have shorter sleep trials, and some have free sleep trials with no obligation to buy. Some online mattress companies offer 365-day sleep trials.

Remember that mattress trial periods and warranties have conditions, like a break-in period or return fees. Knowing the terms of the mattress trial period will help you have a smooth and stress-free experience when trying a new mattress. Also, try the edge support during mattress trials so you won’t experience subpar sleep.

A Man Enjoying a New Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)


A break-in period in mattress-free trials is when your body adjusts to the mattress. It’s like breaking in a new pair of shoes; you need time to get used to the fit and feel. This period allows you to assess comfort and support before keeping or returning the product.

The first break-in period is an important part of any sleep trial and usually takes 14 to 30 days of the sleep trial. This period allows your body to get used to the new mattress and the mattress to adjust to your body.

Give the mattress time to have the required break-in period, as it might feel different from what you experienced in-store or during your first few minutes of trying it out.

If the mattress doesn’t meet your expectations after the break-in period, please return through the channels provided by the mattress company during the sleep trial and break-in period.

So, some companies require mattresses to be returned in their original packaging.

Return Policies Concept.

(Credit: Canva)

Return Procedures and Policies

The return process usually starts when a buyer contacts customer service. Return procedures and policies may vary from online mattress companies, including who will pick up and who will shoulder the shipping cost.

Please read the return process and fees before you buy a mattress.

Return shipping, restocking, and old mattress removal fees can add up to the total cost of returning a mattress.

And some brands may offer to exchange the mattress for a different model from their collection.

Mattress Warranties


Understanding a mattress warranty is like having a safety net for your investment. It's a promise from the mattress company to repair or replace any physical defects in the mattress for a certain period, giving you peace of mind and confidence in your mattress purchase.


When evaluating a mattress warranty, caution is key. Please understand what's covered, the duration of the warranty, and whether it offers a full or partial refund if the mattress is defective.

Coverage: What is covered by the warranty? Manufacturing defects, excessive sagging, or anything else?

Duration: How long is the warranty? Most are ten years, but some are shorter or longer.

A Businessman Showing Warranty Word.

(Credit: Canva)

Full or partial refund: Does the warranty offer a full or partial refund if the mattress is defective?

Full or partial refund: Does the warranty offer a full or partial refund if the mattress is defective?

Please read the fine print carefully and understand the terms before you buy. A full warranty from mattress manufacturers will give you peace of mind and protection against manufacturing defects, so your investment in a new mattress is secured.

Additional tips for evaluating mattress warranties:

Compare warranties from other brands: Not all warranties are created equal. Some brands offer better warranties than others.

When understanding a mattress warranty, don’t just scan the document. Take the time to read it thoroughly and understand all the terms. This diligence will ensure you fully know your rights and the mattress's coverage.

Please get in touch with the mattress company’s customer service if you have questions about the warranty. They should be happy to answer them and help you out.

A Family Enjoying their Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Types of Mattress Warranties

A limited warranty is a promise from the manufacturer to repair or replace any physical defects in a mattress, usually within a certain period.

A full replacement warranty will replace the mattress if it has physical defects within the specified period.

A prorated warranty is a promise from the manufacturer to repair or replace the mattress if it has physical defects within a certain period. However, over time, the warranty's coverage will decrease. In simpler terms, it means that the longer you've had the mattress, the less the warranty will cover in case of a defect.

What Can Void a Warranty

Misuse, abuse, and neglect can void a mattress warranty. Examples of customer neglect are not taking care of the mattress, such as not using a mattress protector or not rotating it regularly. These actions can lead to damage that the warranty may not cover.

An improper foundation or frame that does not meet the manufacturer’s specifications, such as using a box spring not designed for the mattress, can void the mattress warranty.

Staining, soiling, and fluid damage are all forms of damage that can void a mattress warranty if not addressed immediately.

Please, follow the manufacturer’s care instructions to keep your warranty valid.

Comparing Return Policies

When buying a new mattress, comparing return policies is key.

Understanding the return policy of each brand will help you know what’s covered and what fees you’ll incur if you return the wrong mattress anyway.

Some mattress companies have no restocking or return fees, while others have more strict conditions or extra fees.

Hidden fees

When returning a mattress, hidden fees are to be considered. Some companies may charge return shipping fees or restocking fees, which can add up and affect the total cost of the return.

Know these fees and factor them in when choosing a new mattress to return your mattress to.

Also, shipping costs may be higher for remote areas, so this should be considered when returning a mattress.

Some mattress companies may also void the free trial period if the mattress is ordered from a certain location, so it’s important to know any location-specific terms and conditions that apply to your mattress trial.

A person testing a New Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Pickup Arrangements

Convenient pickup arrangements are important for remote users who need to return a mattress.

Mattress pickup arrangements collect a mattress from the customer’s location, which can vary depending on the company or service provider.

This can be scheduling a pickup date, putting the mattress out for regular garbage collection, or making special arrangements in advance.

You can choose a company with the best pickup arrangements for your location and situation. A smooth and hassle-free pickup and return process will make the mattress return process much easier and less stressful.

Mattresses with Exceptional Trial Periods and Warranties

After considering all the factors and knowing the importance of trial periods and warranties, we’ve compiled a list of mattresses with the longest trial periods and warranties.

These mattresses are Puffy Lux Hybrid (101-night sleep trial) and Nolah Natural (120-night sleep trial).

Brands with Longest Sleep Mattress Trial

DreamCloud, Level Sleep, Awara, Avocado Vegan, and Nectar Memory Foam are the brands that offer the longest sleep trial of 365 days. This gives the customer enough time to test and adjust to their new mattress.

These have trial periods, strong warranties, and high customer satisfaction.

Remember that each individual’s preferences and needs may vary, so consider each new mattress’s features and benefits before deciding. The key is to find the right mattress that fits your unique sleeping style, comfort preference, and budget.

Best Overall Mattress

Puffy Lux Hybrid mattress is our top pick for the best overall mattress. It offers a 101-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty. This mattress is designed with foam layers and a cooling gel layer, perfect for hot sleepers.

What sets Puffy Lux Hybrid apart from most mattresses is its overall sleeping experience that caters to different sleep positions and preferences.

With a balance of comfort and support, this is a great option for those looking for a high-quality mattress with a long trial period and warranty.

A Woman Enjoying a New Mattress .

(Credit: Canva)

Best Budget-Friendly Mattress

Nectar Memory Foam is a great option for those looking for a budget-friendly option. This mattress has a one-year free trial and financing with 0% APR through Affirm, so it’s affordable without compromising quality and comfort.

The Nectar Memory Foam mattress has several layers of foam and cooling gel, support and more pressure relief for different sleep positions and for those who sleep hot.

With a lifetime warranty backing up its quality, the Nectar Memory Foam mattress is a smart choice for those looking for a budget-friendly new mattress with a long free trial period and strong warranty coverage.

Tips for Maximizing Your Mattress Trial Experience

How to Make the Most of Your Mattress Trial

Here are some tips to help you maximize your mattress trial. First, try the mattress in different sleep positions and pay attention to how it feels to your body weight and contours.

Monitor your sleep quality during the new mattress trial period, which will help you determine whether the mattress is right for you.

Apart from comfort and support testing, please ensure the mattress is placed in the right room where it should be. This will help with heat retention and reduce off-gassing odors from the mattress, making your mattress trial experience more comfortable.

By following these tips you can make the most of your mattress sleep trial and decide to keep or return the mattress.

How should an innerspring mattress be used during a sleep trial? Set it up properly, keep it clean, and rotate it regularly.

A Young Black Couple Enjoying Their Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Testing Comfort and Support

Remember how it feels to lie down when testing comfort and support during the trial period.

Try lying in different positions, such as back, side, or stomach, and see how the mattress reacts to your body weight and contours.

Pay attention to pressure relief, edge support, and how the mattress supports your spine in different sleeping positions.

Testing its comfort and support allows you to determine if the mattress is right for you. Remember that your body may take some time to adjust to a new mattress, so be patient and give yourself enough time to fully experience it during the trial period.

Monitoring Sleep Quality

Monitoring your sleep quality during the mattress trial period is crucial to determine if the mattress is for you.

You can track your sleep patterns and comfort levels using wearable devices or smartphone applications like Oura Ring, Fitbit Inspire 2, or Sleep Cycle app.

These tools will give you insights into your sleep quality, such as heart rate, movement, and sleep stages.

By tracking your sleep quality during the new mattress trial period, you can make a more informed decision about whether the mattress is right for you.

If you see improvement in your sleep quality it’s a good sign the mattress is for you.

If your sleep quality declines or doesn’t improve, you can return the mattress and try another one.

A Young Man back Sleeping on a Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

How to Choose the Right Mattress Online

Choosing the right mattress can be tough. But there are ways to make the process easier and more successful.

Reading customer ratings and reviews can give you insights into the mattress quality, customer service, and other customer satisfaction.

Comparing brands and offers will help you find the best mattress for you.

By taking the time to research and compare mattress brands thoroughly, you can make a more informed decision about which mattress is for you.

When buying a new mattress online, consider your budget, sleeping position, body type, and desired materials.

This will help you find the mattress that’s perfect for you.

Reading Customer Reviews

Reading customer reviews is key to selecting and buying a mattress online. These reviews will inform you about the mattress quality, customer service, and other customers' satisfaction.

When reading customer reviews, look for common themes or issues.

Also consider the credibility of the reviews and both positive and negative reviews.

Amerisleep, Casper, Purple, and Sleep Number offer a money-back guarantee in their mattress sleep trials. Each company’s warranty covers different situations; returned mattresses may have additional conditions. Make sure to read the fine print to avoid surprise fees.

By reading customer reviews carefully, you can learn about the pros and cons of a mattress and potential issues that may arise.

This will help you make a more informed decision when choosing the right mattress and have a more satisfying buying experience.

An African American Sleeping on Their Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Comparing Brands and Offers

Comparing different online mattress companies and offers is another step to choosing the right mattress online. When comparing online mattress brands and offers, consider mattress type, firmness, support for different sleeping positions, temperature control, motion isolation, durability, price, and return policy/warranty.

You can find the perfect one by comparing and evaluating different brands and offers.

You can make a smart decision and invest in a mattress that will provide you with a comfortable and supportive sleeping surface for years.


Choosing the right mattress online means understanding the mattress trial period, warranty, and return policy.

Following this guide, you can decide better and choose the perfect mattress.

Don’t wait—take advantage of the mattress trial period and warranty to ensure you’re investing in a mattress that will give you the sleep you deserve.

Happy Couple Comfortably Enjoying their Their Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens to mattresses that are returned after the sleep trials?

Several mattress companies offer a free trial period during which customers can donate their mattresses if unsatisfied with their purchase. In some cases, new mattresses can be recycled or thrown away.

Some companies will even repurpose the returned mattress and sell it at a lower price. So returned mattresses have plenty of options to be put to good use.

How long should I try a mattress before returning it?

Try out a new mattress for at least 30 days before you return it. Get used to your new bed and ensure it fits you. Give yourself time to decide if this is the bed for you, but don’t wait beyond the return window!

Young Man Soundly Sleeping on a Mattress.

(Credit: Canva)

Are mattress trials worth it?

If you’re still unsure about the type of mattress you want, a mattress trial will help you make a more informed decision. You can try out different mattresses in person or online before you commit, and this will give you feedback on the support, comfort, and feel of each mattress.

Can I return a mattress if I don't like it?

You can probably return the mattress if you don’t like it, as most companies will allow returns. But check their policy online or in person before buying online to know of any limitations.

Share this post